Are Your Comment Settings Making It Harder For Readers To Comment?

Leaving a comment on a blog post should be simple process. Trouble is that’s often not the case!

As a blogger you need to make it really easy for your readers to leave comments. Unfortunately many bloggers don’t realise their blog’s settings hamper the commenting process. So let me share my comment pet peeves to help you make it easier for your readers to comment (this post was inspired by Claire Thompson’s excellent Comment Pet Peeve post).

# 1 Registered Users Only Allowed to Comment

Image of Log in comment

The words “You must log in to post a comment” means the blogger is only allowing registered users of the blog to comment i.e. each user must be manually as a user (using the User Tab) for them to be able to comment.

There are probably some valid reasons why bloggers have their blog set to only registered users of your blog allowed to comment. But for a reader it’s really frustrating when you know you can add to the conversation but you can’t leave a comment.

This will happen if you tick Users must be registered and logged in to comment in your General Options Tab. Don’t use this setting if you want anyone to be able to comment!

Image of registered user setting

#2 Only allow people with Blogger or Google accounts to comment

Image of blogger settingBlogger makes it really easy for people who use Blogger to leave comments but harder for people who use other blogging platforms.

Why? Well when I leave a comment I want to link my name to my blog so people can easily check it out if they want to.

The default setting when you set up a blog with Blogger is only allow people with Blogger or Google accounts to comment. If you use this setting it means when I leave a comment my name is linked to my blogger blog (which I don’t want it to) and I have to manually add my blog name under my comment using HTML.

Claire’s Comment Pet Peeve post explains how to change your setting in blogger to allow anyone to comment.

Image of Blogger informationHave to say my other peeve with blogger is most other blogging platforms remember your user information if you’ve previously posted a comment on that blog but blogger doesn’t unless you use blogger. Which means each time I have to add my name and blog URL.

#3 Comment Moderation

Comment moderation means your comment must be approved by the blogger before the comment is displayed. I’m not a fan of comment moderation because:

  1. Occasionally I get caught out and aren’t sure if the comment is being moderated or it’s failed to post
  2. Slows down the conversation and if several readers post comments at the same time you have no idea what the others have said

While there are some valid reasons for moderating comments in most circumstances my personal belief is it’s better not to moderate comments (UPDATE: Please take the time to read the readers comments as many raised very valid reasons why you would moderate comments).

Edublogs default settings for new blogs is to moderate comments for readers who haven’t commented on your blog previously (once approved further comments by the same reader aren’t moderated).

The image below shows the default settings:

Image of Comment moderation

Change default settings so comments aren’t moderated at all by:

  1. On your blog dashboard, go to Settings > Discussion
  2. Remove tick from Comment author must have a previously approved comment
  3. Click Save Changes at bottom of page

Image of changing comment moderation setting

NOTE:

While I personally don’t recommend comment moderation on most blogs I think comment moderation (by the teacher) is good practice on student blogs.

Your Thoughts

These are my main comment pet peeves (except for those anti-spam words that have attitude!). What are your main comment pet peeves? What are your thoughts on comment moderation?

If you are enjoying reading this blog, please consider Subscribing For Free!

Why Does Technorati Still Mock Me?

Why me? I’ve been good (mostly). And yet Technorati doesn’t like me and has been mocking (driven me crazy) all weekend! Friends are meant to play nicely aren’t they?

Admittedly people might question why care if Technorati likes you. To be honest, I don’t, except:

  • There are bloggers who prefer to read posts by subscribing to technorati tags than to subscribing to individual blogs.
  • People use blog search engines to locate blogs worth reading.
  • RSS feed from a technorati tag can be used to collect posts when a group uses a common tag

Using RSS from a technorati tag to bring posts by groups is a powerful feature which can be used to bring all posts written by the group to one location to be easily located and read. e.g. Comment Challenge participants are tagging their posts comment08 and latest posts written by participants are automatically added to one central location on the wiki plus they can add the RSS feed from the tag to their feed reader e.g. Google Reader, Bloglines, NetVibes.

As a blogger it’s important to optimise your blog visibility so your posts are easily found on Technorati.

About Technorati

Technorati and Google Blog Search are both search engines used for searching keyword (i.e. tag) or category used to describe the subject matter or topic of a blog post. Technorati is generally better at locating posts than Google Blog Search.

If you want your blog to appear in technorati blog search directory and your posts to be found in their searches you need to join Technorati and then claim your blog.

technorati.jpg

Below is an example of how your blog will look to others once you have claimed your blog.

mobiletech.jpg

Authority is the number of blogs linking to your website in the last six months. The higher the number, the more Technorati Authority your blog has. Technorait measures the number of blogs, rather than the number of links. So, if a blog links to your blog many times, it still only count as +1 toward your authority.

The blog with the highest Technorati Authority is the #1 ranked blog. Your Rank is calculated based on how far you are from the top ranking blog. The smaller your Technorati Rank, the closer you are to the top.

Searching Technorati

You can do a basic search or an advanced search on Technorati. As most people use basic search and since technorati’s basic search searches for the keywords within posts it’s a good idea to include keywords, and variations of keywords, when writing your post (provided it doesn’t detract from readability).

For example if I wrote a post about mlearning I may include words like mobile learning, m-learning and mobile technologies within the text of my post. Unfortunately Technorati doesn’t recognise words like m-learning as a search term and this needs to be written as mlearning.

You can subscribe to the RSS feed from technorati searches using your feed reader or add the RSS feed to another site e.g. like we have done with the Comment Challenge wiki. We’ve needed to refine our searches to capture more posts.

technoratisearches.jpg

This refined search was used for adding the RSS feed from the comment08 tag to our wiki so participants can check latest posts.

rss-wiki-feed.jpg

The better option for a group to receive latest posts is to subscribe to the RSS feed from technorati using their feed reader.

technoratigr.jpg

What We Need You To Do For The Comment Challenge

Encouraging the community aspect is an important part of the Comment Challenge. We need for all posts from the Challenge to be included in the RSS feed from Technorati so participants can easily find each other and interact. With over 100 adult participants and 8 student groups (over 200 students) technorati is the most efficient method of bringing together all posts.

For all adult participants we need you to:

  1. If you are recording your reflections on a blog — Join and claim your blog at Technorati
  2. If you have a blog already claimed on technorati — can you please log into Technorati and ping your blog (some of your blogs haven’t accessed posts from your blog for 90 days which means we won’t see any of the posts you are writing).pingtechnorati.jpg
  3. Tag all posts written for the Challenge using comment08 – refer to instructions on the challenge wiki.
  4. Add the RSS feed from the technorati comment08 tag to your Feed Reader (preferably Google Reader so that you can do a search of this RSS feed using Google Reader to make sure your posts are included).
  5. If you aren’t blogging your learning journey but are recording them using another online tool please add it’s location to your participants details. If you want to set up your own blog go here to create your blog for free! (here’s our Getting Started with Edublogs page with lots of “How to” manuals and videos to get you going).
  6. Refer to this information for how to tag comments you write during this Challenge.

This is how you tag your posts if you use Edublogs.

For student participants please:

  1. Don’t use comment08 tag with your student — instead use the tag studentcomment08
  2. Liaise with the other teachers in the challenge to coordinate your activities.

FINAL THOUGHTS

If you’re wondering why technorati drove me crazy this weekend — it has taken me considerable time to realise all the different reasons why all posts weren’t being found. Hopefully this information helps you understand how to use technorati better.

If you are enjoying reading this blog, please consider Subscribing For Free!

How keep track of new comments on other bloggers’ posts

Frustrated because you like to know about new comments on other bloggers’ posts , especially if you’ve left a comment, but find it time consuming going back to the post to check for new comment?

Well you don’t need to return to where you wrote the comments because you can get them brought to you using a comment tracking tool. Part of the The 31 Day Comment Challenge involves using comment tracking tools. Since it’s suggested participants use coComment because of it’s community building features let’s check out tips for getting started with coComment.

Tracking Comments

  1. Create an account with coComment.
  2. Install simple extension capture tool.capturetool.jpg
  3. Join the Comment Challenge Group if you are doing The 31 Day Comment Challenge.
  4. The coComment extension automatically sends comments you write to your coComment account (plus you can tag your comments).
    addingcomment.jpg

Checking For New Comments

There are several few options for viewing new comments:

1. Login into Your coComment account

cocommentweb.jpg

While reading the new comments remember to share your comments with your groups.

cocomentshare.jpg

2. Subscribing to the RSS feed from your coComment account

This means all new comments are fed into your feed reader (e.g. Google Reader, bloglines) and you can check them while reading your blog subscriptions.

cocommentrss.jpg

3. Using the coComment sidebar

You can access the coComment Sidebar on any web page using the shortcut keys Shift+Ctrl+Q (these keys can also be used for turning off).

Watch this video to see how to use the coComment sidebar.

Final Thoughts

Hopefully this has helped get you started using coComment. While we encourage all Comment Challenge participants to use coComment because of it’s community features — it’s not a requirement of the challenge that you do.

Also don’t forget to document your learning while completing the Comment Challenge — as Silva says

If you don’t have a blog (yet), take a paper and a pencil and jot down bullets. Remember this challenge is mainly about your own personal learning. The community effect is, of course, an added bonus

If you want to start a blog, or are new to blogging, check out our Getting Started with Edublogs page because we have lots of “How to” manuals and videos to get you going. Go here to create your blog for free!

If you are enjoying reading this blog, please consider Subscribing For Free!